Cinotti's Bakery

Cinotti's Bakery is the Jacksonville Beach bakery and sandwich shop at 1523 Penman Road, Jacksonville Beach, FL 32250. Google Places lists the phone as (904) 246-1728 and the match title as Cinotti's Bakery-Sandwich Shop. This Stay Safe Jax page is the Penman Road bakery. It is not a Town Center pastry counter, not a San Marco-only history page, and not a Downtown JTA kiosk treated as this Google card. The Florida Times-Union’s September 27, 2019, pumpkin doughnut story placed Cinotti’s at 1523 Penman Road, said Mike Cinotti’s grandfather Nick opened the first bakery in Cleveland in 1936, said the family moved to Jacksonville in the mid-1950s, and said Mike and Doodle Cinotti opened a sandwich shop at the Penman Road location in 1985 and added the bakery in 1990. News4JAX reported on November 6, 2025, that Cinotti’s Bakery and Sandwich Shop won the JAXBest 2025 best bakery vote and listed the same 1523 Penman Road address with Tuesday through Saturday 6:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. hours. Stay Safe Jax does not link the bakery’s own website. Public ratings on this page are stored snapshots, not live scores. Google Places currently lists Cinotti's Bakery-Sandwich Shop at 4.5 from 1,466 reviews for the 1523 Penman Road listing, the same place ID stored here. Stay Safe Jax has no stored Yelp rating, so the headline is the Google snapshot: 4.5 from 1,466 reviews. Those numbers do not refresh when someone opens the page. Google currently lists closed Monday, Tuesday through Saturday 6:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., and closed Sunday, matching the News4JAX hours note. Hours change. Check Google the day you go. Google lists wheelchair parking, entrance, and restroom, and does not list wheelchair seating. Stay Safe Jax did not inspect the shop and does not treat a missing seating tag as a scandal. Stay Safe Jax leaves warning flags at 0. Cinotti's is a well-reviewed Jacksonville Beach bakery and sandwich restaurant with a large Google snapshot, posted morning hours, and sourced Times-Union and News4JAX coverage. The tone follows that evidence. Jacksonville Beach residents looking for a bakery on Penman Road should use the Google Maps place ID on this page. A 4.5 Google snapshot from 1,466 reviews is a strong Beaches bakery score, and it is still only a snapshot. The Times-Union pumpkin doughnut story is local tradition coverage, not a complaint. JAXBest is a reader poll, not a health inspection.