Orsay

Restaurant•Avondale
Avondale restaurantFrenchInsetta
4.60EXTERNAL RATING
3,629 external review signalsAverage 4.60 from Google 4.7 (2,366 reviews) and Yelp 4.5 (1,263 reviews)

External Reputation Indicators

Google rating
4.7/5.0
2,366 external review signalsView source
Yelp rating
4.5/5.0
1,263 external review signalsView source
Research What Jacksonville residents should know
Restaurant Orsay is the Avondale French restaurant at 3630 Park Street, Jacksonville, FL 32205. Google Places lists the phone as (904) 381-0909. This Stay Safe Jax page is Restaurant Orsay in Avondale. It is not Black Sheep Restaurant in Five Points, not Bellwether, and not a downtown bar. Jonathan Insetta owns Orsay. Public coverage used here dates the dining room to 2008 and names chef Michael McKinney. Stay Safe Jax does not link the restaurant’s own website. Public ratings on this page are stored snapshots, not live scores. Google Places currently lists Restaurant Orsay at 4.7 from 2,366 reviews for the 3630 Park Street listing, the same place ID stored here and the same match title: Restaurant Orsay. Stay Safe Jax has no stored Yelp rating, so the headline is the Google snapshot: 4.7 from 2,366 reviews. Those numbers do not refresh when someone opens the page. Google currently lists the restaurant closed Monday, Tuesday through Thursday 4:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m., Friday 4:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m., Saturday 11:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m., and Sunday 11:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. Hours change. OpenTable also publishes a reservation listing for Restaurant Orsay Jacksonville, which Stay Safe Jax treats as a booking page, not a news article. Check Google or OpenTable the day you go. The Jacksonville Daily Record reported on April 28, 2023 that Black Sheep Restaurant in Five Points was closing because of pandemic-induced price hikes and that the closing did not affect Orsay. That is the sourced line that keeps this Avondale restaurant open in the catalog after Black Sheep shut. Arbus later described a new menu and renovations at Orsay. Those pieces are dining coverage, not lawsuits or license actions. Stay Safe Jax does not invent investigations for a well-reviewed Avondale French restaurant. Stay Safe Jax leaves warning flags at 0. Restaurant Orsay is an Avondale Jacksonville restaurant with a strong Google snapshot, posted hours, Insetta ownership that is public in local coverage, and sourced stories that separate it from a closed Five Points room. The tone follows that evidence. Avondale diners who remember Black Sheep should read the 2023 Daily Record story linked here: the Five Points closing did not take Orsay with it. Restaurant Orsay remains the Park Street French restaurant Jonathan Insetta opened in 2008, with chef Michael McKinney named in the public coverage used on this page. OpenTable is a reservation listing, not a newspaper. Arbus is magazine coverage of a menu and renovation, not a consumer complaint. Stay Safe Jax does not link the restaurant’s own site. A 4.7 Google snapshot from 2,366 reviews is a strong Avondale restaurant score, and it is still only a snapshot.
Place

Restaurant Orsay is the Avondale French restaurant at 3630 Park Street, Jacksonville 32205, owned by Jonathan Insetta.

Ratings

The stored Google snapshot is 4.7 from 2,366 reviews. Stay Safe Jax has no Yelp card. Scores on this page are not live.

Record

The Daily Record wrote in April 2023 that Black Sheep’s closing did not affect Orsay. Arbus covered later menu and renovation work.

Frequently Asked Questions

Google Places lists Restaurant Orsay at 3630 Park Street, Jacksonville, FL 32205, in Avondale. The phone is (904) 381-0909.
Jonathan Insetta owns Orsay. Chef Michael McKinney is the chef named in public coverage. The Jacksonville Daily Record reported in April 2023 that Black Sheep’s closing did not affect Orsay. Black Sheep was a separate Five Points restaurant.
As stored in September 2026, Google Places lists 4.7 from 2,366 reviews for Restaurant Orsay. That snapshot is not live. Stay Safe Jax has no stored Yelp rating, so the headline is 4.7.
Google currently lists the restaurant closed Monday, Tuesday through Thursday 4:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m., Friday 4:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m., Saturday 11:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m., and Sunday 11:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. Hours change. Check Google or OpenTable the day you go.
Public coverage used on this page dates Restaurant Orsay to 2008 in Avondale. Arbus later described menu and renovation updates. Stay Safe Jax does not link the restaurant’s own website.

Community Notes

0 published

No approved community notes yet.

Stay Safe Jax Reviews

0 approved

No native Stay Safe Jax community reviews have been approved for this business yet. Submitted ratings are held in moderation before publishing.