Stay Safe Jax community trust ratings
DirectoryHow it worksSafety SignalsBlogGet listedShare a rating
Home/Directory/Safe Harbor Seafood Restaurant

Safe Harbor Seafood Restaurant

Restaurant•Mayport
Mayport seafoodMayport shrimpOcean Street
4.40EXTERNAL RATING
6,896 external review signalsAverage 4.40 from Google 4.5 (5,989 reviews) and Yelp 4.3 (907 reviews)

External Reputation Indicators

Google rating
4.5/5.0
5,989 external review signalsView source
Yelp rating
4.3/5.0
907 external review signalsView source
Research What Jacksonville residents should know
Safe Harbor Seafood Restaurant is the Mayport seafood restaurant at 4378 Ocean Street #3, Atlantic Beach, FL 32233, in Mayport Village. Google Places lists the phone as (904) 246-4911. This Stay Safe Jax page is the Ocean Street restaurant. It is not the retail market across the street at 4371 Ocean Street, not Sliders oyster bar in Neptune Beach, and not a Jacksonville Beach fish shack. Google’s postal city is Atlantic Beach. Visit Jacksonville and local news still call the room Mayport. Stay Safe Jax keeps the neighborhood as Mayport because that is the working waterfront, not Jacksonville Beach. Visit Jacksonville lists Safe Harbor Seafood Market and Restaurant-Mayport at 4378 Ocean Street #3 and describes a casual waterfront seafood restaurant with a market for local catch. The Mayport Village visitor page names Safe Harbor as a favorite serving local seafood on the working waterfront, with the market across the street. News4Jax named Safe Harbor JAXBest 2025 best seafood on November 7, 2025, and described the restaurant at 4378 Ocean Street plus the market and the related Sliders room. An earlier August 22, 2022, News4Jax JAXBest story also named Safe Harbor for Mayport shrimp. Stay Safe Jax does not add the company’s own website. Public ratings on this page are stored snapshots, not live scores. Google Places currently lists Safe Harbor Seafood Restaurant at 4.5 from 5,989 reviews for the 4378 Ocean Street listing, the same place ID stored here. Stay Safe Jax has no stored Yelp rating, so the headline is the Google snapshot: 4.5 from 5,989 reviews. Those numbers do not refresh when someone opens the page. Google currently lists Monday closed, Tuesday through Thursday 11:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m., Friday and Saturday 11:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m., and Sunday 11:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. Hours change. Check Google the day you go to Mayport. Google Places lists wheelchair-accessible parking, entrance, restroom, and seating. Stay Safe Jax did not independently inspect the waterfront room. Call ahead if you need a specific accommodation. Stay Safe Jax leaves warning flags at 0. There is no current sourced lawsuit, investigation, or safety warning in the facts used here. Safe Harbor is an ordinary Mayport seafood restaurant with a large Google snapshot and a Monday close. The tone follows that evidence.
Place

Safe Harbor Seafood Restaurant is the Mayport seafood room at 4378 Ocean Street #3 — not the market across the street and not Sliders.

Ratings

The stored Google snapshot is 4.5 from 5,989 reviews. Stay Safe Jax has no Yelp card. Scores are not live.

Record

News4Jax named Safe Harbor JAXBest 2025 best seafood. Visit Jacksonville lists the same Ocean Street address.

Sources & resources
Rating sourceGoogle business listing and ratingRating sourceYelp business listing and ratingVisit JacksonvilleSafe Harbor Seafood Market and Restaurant-MayportVisit JacksonvilleMayport VillageNewsSafe Harbor reels in top honors as best seafood in Jacksonville for JAXBest 2025NewsJacksonville’s best Mayport shrimp: Safe Harbor Seafood Market & Restaurant

Frequently Asked Questions

Google Places lists 4378 Ocean Street #3, Atlantic Beach, FL 32233. Visit Jacksonville files it in Mayport Village. The phone is (904) 246-4911.
As stored in September 2026, Google Places lists 4.5 from 5,989 reviews. That snapshot is not live. Stay Safe Jax has no stored Yelp rating, so the headline is 4.5.
No. Visit Jacksonville and News4Jax describe a restaurant at 4378 Ocean Street and a market across the street. This page is the restaurant listing.
Google currently lists Monday closed, Tuesday through Thursday 11:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m., Friday and Saturday 11:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m., and Sunday 11:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. Hours change. Check Google the day you go.
Google Places currently lists wheelchair-accessible parking, entrance, restroom, and seating. Stay Safe Jax did not independently inspect. Call (904) 246-4911 if you need a specific accommodation.

Community Notes

0 published

No approved community notes yet.

Stay Safe Jax Reviews

0 approved

No native Stay Safe Jax community reviews have been approved for this business yet. Submitted ratings are held in moderation before publishing.

November 7, 2025 · News4Jax

Safe Harbor reels in top honors as best seafood in Jacksonville for JAXBest 2025

News4Jax named the Mayport restaurant at 4378 Ocean Street the JAXBest 2025 seafood winner.

Open original article

Published references

Sources & supporting documents

These are the Google, Yelp, news, BBB, government, and other public pages currently stored for this profile. Links open the original source so residents can review the information directly.

Rating source

Rating source

Google business listing and rating

Matched listing: Safe Harbor Seafood Restaurant

Rating captured Sep 7, 2026
Open source
Rating source

Yelp business listing and rating

Matched listing: Safe Harbor Seafood

Rating captured Jun 12, 2026
Open source

Visit Jacksonville

Visit Jacksonville

Safe Harbor Seafood Market and Restaurant-Mayport

Open source
Visit Jacksonville

Mayport Village

Open source

News

News

Safe Harbor reels in top honors as best seafood in Jacksonville for JAXBest 2025

Open source
News

Jacksonville’s best Mayport shrimp: Safe Harbor Seafood Market & Restaurant

Open source

Source links document where information was found. External ratings and business details can change after the capture date.

Score breakdown

Safety86%
Accessibility88%
Response84%

Report incorrect info

See a wrong detail or outdated claim? Tell us what needs correction and it goes straight to the Stay Safe Jax team.

Submit a review

Tags

Add a community note